Foreword
With great pleasure and anticipation, we extend our heartfelt greetings to each of you as we stand on the precipice of unveiling the outcomes of the "Beyond the Boundaries Design Competition." This journey, marked by creativity, innovation, and the relentless pursuit of architectural excellence, has been nothing short of inspiring.
From the outset, Archiol set out to challenge the conventional, encouraging participants to transcend limits and redefine the very boundaries that often confine architectural imagination. Your responses, diverse and ingenious, have not only met but exceeded our expectations, proving that the architectural spirit knows no bounds.
This competition was not just an exploration of design concepts; it was a collective endeavor to push the envelope, break free from the norm, and envisage spaces that resonate with the ethos of tomorrow. The submissions we received were not merely entries; they were visions, dreams, and manifestos of a future where architecture becomes the embodiment of limitless possibilities.
As we prepare to reveal the results in this virtual space, we recognize and commend the passion, dedication, and sheer brilliance each participant brought to the competition. Your commitment to pushing boundaries and exploring the uncharted territories of architectural design has left an indelible mark on the ethos of Archiol.
Top 3
FIRST
Rémi Koumakpayi, Markhly Delva Estelle Contant & Youssef Safi Laimeche
Canada
SECOND
Minzhe Li and Wenjing Wang
China
THIRD
Cormac Dillon, Alwin Holden Bobbett
Ireland
FIRST PRIZE WINNER
___________________
Being(s) Boundaries
Rémi Koumakpayi, Markhly Delva Estelle Contant & Youssef Safi Laimeche
Canada
JURY COMMENTS
The concept of using human interactions as dynamic boundaries in the perception of space is highly innovative and creative. The incorporation of playfulness to explore this notion adds a unique dimension to the installation. The analogue experiences of rocking and mist effectively represent the impact of human actions on space.
The design considers spatial interaction and user experience by incorporating a rocking platform and mist nozzles. These elements engage participants in a physical and sensory manner, allowing them to experience the impact of their presence on the space. The emphasis on playfulness enhances the user experience, encouraging a more immersive exploration of the concept.
The choice of Place de la Paix in downtown Montreal as the location for the installation seems suitable for fostering public engagement. The use of scaffolding and plywood, along with a non-slip rubber finish, indicates a consideration for materials that can be easily dismounted and leave the area unharmed. However, the extent of integration with the immediate surroundings could be further explored to ensure a seamless blend with the urban environment.
The design aligns exceptionally well with the theme of Beyond the Boundaries by exploring the dynamic and often intangible factors that shape our perception of space. The choice of human beings as boundaries and the incorporation of analog experiences effectively convey the theme's essence. The rocking platform and mist nozzles successfully translate the conceptual ideas into tangible interactions.
Overall, Being(s) Boundaries demonstrates a strong and thought-provoking design that excels in conceptual alignment with the theme and innovative exploration of human interactions in spatial perception. The integration with surroundings could be further refined, but the overall execution is commendable.
SECOND PRIZE WINNER
___________________
Transforming Decay into Magic
Minzhe Li and Wenjing Wang
China
JURY COMMENTS
The concept of transforming decay into magic through lacquer art is highly innovative and creative. The use of an unassuming exterior that comes to life with human participation, creating a constellation-like effect, is unique and captivating. The idea of allowing individuals to interact with the installation by "polishing" the lacquerware adds an extra layer of creativity.
The design emphasizes user engagement by inviting people to actively participate in the transformation of the installation. The incorporation of a recessed pathway and the gradual emanation of gentle light contribute to a dynamic spatial experience. The interactive element of revealing patterns by reaching out to "polish" the lacquerware enhances the overall user experience.
While the design doesn't explicitly describe its integration with the surroundings, the use of inconspicuous colors suggests an attempt to blend in with the environment. However, further details about how the installation interacts with the existing architecture and landscape would enhance the overall integration with the surroundings.
The design aligns perfectly with the theme of "Transforming Decay into Magic." The metaphorical use of lacquer art to bring life to decay is well-executed, and the exploration of lacquerware as a magical realm aligns seamlessly with the theme. The incorporation of Fuzhou's Zhuzi Alley adds a cultural and contextual layer to the concept.
Overall, the design is impressive and scores high in terms of innovative concept, creativity, user experience, and thematic alignment. The integration with surroundings could be further detailed, but the overall vision of transforming decay into magic is effectively communicated.
THIRD PRIZE WINNER
___________________
Shelter
Cormac Dillon, Alwin Holden Bobbett
Ireland
JURY COMMENTS
The design demonstrates a highly innovative and creative concept by reinterpreting traditional Irish cottages to create a modern sanctuary in the heart of the city. The use of tall, swooping walls and a beacon-like chimney adds a unique and visually striking element. The incorporation of a hearth as the central focus aligns with the traditional concept while introducing a modern twist.
The design appears to offer an engaging spatial experience with multiple entrances of varying heights and pitches, guiding visitors through concrete funnels to the lit hearth. The sheltered seating around the hearth encourages conversation and rest, fostering a sense of community. The raised platform adds a dynamic element for exploration and interaction with the overhead structure. However, further details on the flow and functionality of the space would enhance the evaluation.
The concept of reinterpreting traditional cottages for an urban setting is interesting, but the success of integration with surroundings might depend on the existing architectural context of Eyre Square, Galway. The tall, swooping walls may either complement or contrast with the surroundings, and a more detailed description or visualization of the integration is needed for a thorough evaluation.
The design appears to align well with the theme of Beyond the Boundaries, as it creatively pushes the boundaries of traditional concepts to create a contemporary sanctuary. The use of the hearth as a central element connects with the theme of storytelling and community, offering a space for people to come together and escape the noise of city life.
Overall, the design shows great promise and creativity, with attention to both traditional and modern elements.
SPECIAL MENTION
___________________
JURY COMMENTS
Honorable Mention
HONOURABLE MENTION
___________________
JURY COMMENTS
HONOURABLE MENTION
___________________
JURY COMMENTS
HONOURABLE MENTION
___________________
JURY COMMENTS
HONOURABLE MENTION
___________________
JURY COMMENTS
HONOURABLE MENTION
___________________
JURY COMMENTS
Shortlisted Entries
Announcement in Media
Organizers
