The Winners!
INTO THE RABBIT HOLE 2023
First Prize Winners
Yanyun Wang, Jiafei Liu, Wenhan Li & Teng Guo
China
Wang Yanyun
Artist / Director / Designer
Guo Teng
Architect
Li Wenhan
Designer, Teacher
Liu Jiafei
Designer
Introduction
My name is Wang Yanyun, and my English name is Clare. I am thrilled that our team project, HETEROTOPIA, has won first place in the "Into the Rabbit Hole" design competition. I am also excited to present this project to all of you as the lead designer.
But at the beginning, I would like to emphasize a fact, which is that I am not currently a student at any architecture school, nor am I a professional architect with an architectural license. Although I aspire to become a student at the best architecture school someday and make a significant impact as a designer in inclusive design, I believe I still need more time to achieve it.
So, at least in this case, I prefer to introduce myself as a survivor of sexual assault who strongly believes in the healing power of architecture and its potential to create a supportive community for vulnerable people. This is not only because the "Into the Rabbit Hole" competition emphasizes the relationship between architecture and healing, but many architectural designs nowadays also aim to design for the vulnerable and incorporate more moral and humanitarian considerations. However, in certain projects, the vulnerable are often seen as symbols, a group that needs saving and protection, rather than individuals with equal intelligence and vibrant lives like the designers themselves.
Therefore, I believe that today, as a victim and a first-place winner in an interesting and important competition, I can serve as a window to convey a simple but crucial message: "If you want to design something for vulnerable individuals, don't just design for us, but design with us." Because even though we often react slower than others and require more time due to psychological traumas, if you give us more assistance and patience, trust me, we will discover the untapped brilliance within our lives. Furthermore, the challenges we have faced have equipped us with remarkable abilities, such as the ability to empathize with others and understand the pain they go through. This is an ability of great importance, at least for early-stage design, isn't it?
When I initially discovered the competition details for "Into the Rabbit Hole," I promptly registered. In fact, I was captivated by the correlation between the rabbit hole and psychological recovery as it accurately portrays the initial response of individuals seeking healing. Furthermore, with a six-year history of therapy, I firmly believe in the positive impact of the rabbit hole. Currently, I am conducting research on this subject for my thesis under the mentorship of a professor from the Social Psychology department at UCL.
From a psychological perspective, the concept of the rabbit hole embodies two crucial aspects of healing. Firstly, it represents "selective attention,” which means the ability to concentrate solely on one positive aspect while disregarding other potentially traumatic experiences. This mechanism serves as an emergency escape.
Secondly, the rabbit hole holds infinite possibilities for exploration, which can temporarily free trauma sufferers from the grip of their emotional brain and allow the prefrontal cortex to take charge. Even in a brief period, the prefrontal cortex enables us to establish positive connections with the outside world and experience the joy of creativity. For individuals who have endured trauma, this aspect carries even greater significance than emergency escape, as it empowers us to regain a sense of control.
So, in sum, the more rabbit holes people can delve into, the greater their chances of escaping from their own story and finding healing. This is why I registered as soon as I saw the entry for "Into the Rabbit Hole," fortunately, in the following months, I found the most suitable partners for the project.
Design Concept
HETEROTOPIA is a concept design based on Michel Foucault's philosophical theory. It envisions an ideal city, created underground by the people of Aleppo, Syria, in response to the ravages of war. While the surface of Aleppo bears the scars of past colonialism and present international politics, this hidden underground city embodies the timeless elements that have defined Syrian history. Its architectural style draws inspiration from the golden city-state era of Syria, and its design incorporates the original paradigm of Islamic patterns. As Foucault suggests, HETEROTOPIA may be an abstract and intangible concept, but it faithfully reproduces the essence of a space. And only those with great courage and keen powers of observation can uncover and access it.
The main difference between this design and traditional healing architecture is that we didn't start with a specific and rigid environment like a "healing room". Instead, we approached the healing from the perspective of the victims' inner world and used artistic techniques to showcase how they could have lived without experiencing harm. This is because, in psychological healing, the biggest challenge to overcome is the victims' feeling of defeat. Many individuals, due to trauma, struggle to find hope for a fresh start in life. However, by vividly illustrating the potential positive outcomes they can achieve through actively overcoming their pain, it can have a much stronger impact than simply passively listening to their stories of suffering.
I hold this perspective because, even though my experience in architecture is relatively brief, I have already been involved in the construction of several conventional therapeutic structures. In April of this year, my conceptual design for aiding landmine victims in Cambodia was chosen, it granting me the opportunity to attend an international mine clearance conference in Cambodia. During the conference, I had the privilege of meeting numerous local landmine victims. And in August, I traveled to Africa and assumed the role of co-designer for a sustainable development center in Mayukwayukwa, which is Zambia's oldest refugee camp.
After collaborating with three other architects and over 30 refugees from Congo and Angola, we successfully completed the construction of the facility. In these on-site projects, we have made some achievements, such as learning how to quickly build houses using local methods in extreme environments and how to cooperate with the local government.
But there are also some concerning aspects that give me pause. For instance, during our time at the Mayukwayukwa refugee camp, we attempted to collaborate with the refugees on construction projects. However, one day, a refugee shouted at us, "What is your guys' purpose here? Is it just to prove that you are good people? Is the current chaos in the world unrelated to both white people and you Chinese people?" We were shocked by this scene. In our team, we have Americans, Norwegians, Mexicans, and me, Chinese. We were all shocked and whispered, "What happened?”
And my experiences in Cambodia have also reminded me of something similar. When I presented my design to local architects, they expressed their discomfort as politely as possible because they didn't want to embarrass me. But they want me to know that my design focused too heavily on the pain they have endured and only a small part dedicated to hope and rebuilding. As Cambodians, they don't want their country to always be associated with tragedy on the international stage. Instead, they hope that, like China, Cambodia can eventually emerge from the shadows of the past and become a stronger nation.
All this information has led me to reconsider our designs for refugees and the vulnerable. Are these designs truly necessary? Is it truly beneficial for them to collaborate with us in creating what we call "healing architecture"? Can they truly find healing in the architecture that we believe to be effective?
At the same time, I encountered a sudden surge of anger during an interview as the victim, too. Being a well-known survivor of sexual assault in China, there are always journalists and directors who seek to exploit me for news reports or documentary films. The longest tracking shot lasted for a year until I could no longer bear it and asked them, "stop filming immediately.Please "
Because a lot of times, I strongly sensed that the people behind the camera were attempting to diminish my worth. Their lens only captured my moments of vulnerability and tears and some odd life experiences. While deliberately disregarding my professional accomplishments, my confidence as a survivor, and even my ambitious aspirations. This realization made me understand that they never saw me as an ordinary person but merely desired my tear-stricken face as a sensational headline.
These small but significant pieces of information all convey the same message: there are instances where victims and the vulnerable have a unique viewpoint that may differ from our own. Failing to understand their perspective can lead to self-centered actions on our part, which is not conducive to creating architecture that truly promotes healing.
This is also why today, I made the deliberate choice to respond to these interview questions not as a designer but as a victim. We should know Healing architecture encompasses two crucial elements: healing spaces and the individuals who need to be healed. The voices of victims cannot be disregarded. And as victims, what we truly need is not pity. What we truly need is genuine respect and empathy.
Because of these previous practices and reflections, in this competition, in the HETEROTOPIA, I focused on deeply studying the history of Syria and reading Islamic architecture and art page by page. I marveled at their magnificent and splendid culture. In the end, I decided to incorporate their proudest cultural symbols into this design, just as my therapist once told me, "You know what? Without these tragedies, your life could have been better. However, even in the midst of all the unpleasant things happening now, you possess the ability to reclaim what should have belonged to you. I will accompany you until your light shines brighter than the darkness, enough to overshadow it." I hope this can represent a more genuine companionship and a deeper form of healing.
Healing in Architecture
From a psychological standpoint, a healing environment comprises two crucial elements: a sense of safety and a sense of belonging. According to Maslow's theory, these elements are equally important as basic physiological needs like food, water, and air. Therefore, in the design of HETEROTOPIA, our first question is: what should we do if arrogant and belligerent individuals attempt to enter this underground city? Will the people seeking refuge there be at risk? How will they respond to external challenges? To address these concerns, we have designed a fortified barrier that can be controlled by the residents inside.
The second question is how the people living in the underground city can establish a more effective community to provide a sense of belonging for those seeking refuge from war. While contemplating this question, I stumbled upon a competition called "Rebuilding Syria" that took place shortly after the Syrian civil war on a global scale. In this competition, a female architect offered a unique perspective on how a sense of belonging is formed within the local population. Her theory suggests that architectural design can influence people's behavior.
In the Middle East, the architectural transition from tribal to urban took place during the city-state period, with a focus on cohabitation patterns and tolerance psychology. Rooftops became spaces for socializing and playing, and Mohammed used to give speeches on rooftops to attract followers when he established Islam. However, with the colonization by France, Syria's architectural style gradually shifted towards prioritizing separation and privacy. Social symbols such as religion, wealth, and social class became divisive, making it difficult for individuals to establish a sense of national and ethnic community. According to some local architects in Syria, this is the root cause of the outbreak of the civil war.
When I came across this theory, I was surprised by the relationship between war and architectural forms. It urged me to deeply contemplate how we should design an underground city that promotes communication, makes it easier to form a cohesive whole, and helps people find a sense of belonging while respecting the local history.
So, we chose to use five basic modules - family, solitude, religious, commercial, and social - to improve people's connectivity and communication density, while leaving space for independent thinking.
What's even more interesting is that when we feel secure enough to regain control of our brains from the emotional part and shift it to the prefrontal cortex, we have a strong need to communicate with the outside world. So HETEROTOPIA is not a completely closed underground world with zero communication with the outside. Those strange creatures growing in the ruins actually serve as megaphones. And for those of us living in the world above, when we enter the ruins and think that the city is completely dead, we can faintly hear prayers and the shouts of businessmen, as if we never lost the prosperous era. This will further stimulate our thinking about why we lost them and how we can regain them.
True healing has always been about communication and empathy. It's about us collectively striving towards a common goal.
In the design of HETEROTOPIA, the most crucial design element is parametric design, which was also my first encounter with Grasshopper. At the time, we decided to have the computer generate the final model instead of assembling it manually. This approach may appear easier for the designer, but it presents more philosophical choices. For instance, when selecting Islamic patterns for the plan of the underground city, we initially chose many patterns but were unsatisfied because we couldn't explain why we chose one pattern over another. Fortunately, we later discovered a book dedicated to teaching the drawing of Islamic patterns. This book introduced a fundamental pattern that serves as the prototype for many others. This discovery was fascinating and aligned perfectly with our process of using parametric design. Like the book, we also start with one prototype and remain open to the possibilities that may arise along the way, without certainty.
Unconventional Thinking
Hmm, perhaps it is because I was not an architect before, and I am still learning what the architectural paradigm entails. Therefore, I have not yet established this so-called paradigm.
In design, the most inspiring moment occurred when I was explaining my design thinking to Li Wenhan, and he unexpectedly introduced the concept of HETEROTOPIA. In that instant, I couldn't believe how accurately he grasped what I wanted to convey, and within a few minutes, he provided a flawless summary, giving this project a central concept. From that point forward, We steadfastly follow this term, offering detailed explanations for all the subsequent conceptual aspects.
Design Evolution
Our design evolution process is closely tied to the composition of our team.
Before studying architecture full-time, I worked as a director. The documentary films I directed have been viewed by over 500 million viewers in China. My training focused on using visual storytelling to gradually immerse the audience in the world we wanted to create. Therefore, my role in this architecture project is to write the script and discuss with all team members how to use architectural thinking to present this story, which serves as the foundation of its architectural narrative.
On the other hand, Wenhan is currently pursuing a PhD in architectural heritage. He has extensive knowledge of various historical and philosophical concepts, and he came up with a fitting and captivating name for the project, which serves as its conceptual foundation.
GuoTeng is highly skilled in parametric design and wrote a complete set of scripts for the project. Furthermore, he provided training to both me and Liu Jiafei on using these scripts to realize the design, forming the basis of our technical expertise.
Liu Jiafei is a dedicated team member who excels in digital drawing and modeling. Her contribution was essential in creating the visually impressive final presentation, which forms the basis of our visual output. Additionally, Jia Fei has recently started her master's studies at The Bartlett School of Architecture at University College London. There, she will further develop her expertise in advanced coding, manufacturing, and robotics, as well as the latest techniques in artificial intelligence, CNC manufacturing, 3D printing, supercomputing, simulation, and interactivity. She will utilize these technical skills to research automation in architecture and address social justice issues within the field.
Each of us contributed to a new round of design evolution, and we are delighted that we were able to find a balance and showcase each person's strengths perfectly.
Impact on Communities
In practical terms, I don't believe OUR design offers any advantages. Instead, I prefer to view it as a conceptual architecture of the mind. The architecture of the mind is also energy-efficient, as it doesn't require physical construction. I believe this conceptual design has a greater impact on how we perceive the world.
Advice for Future Innovators
I dare not say that I have any suggestions, as mentioned earlier, I am still a newcomer in architecture. However, I am really eager to connect with more outstanding designers. If possible, I would also like to establish a global victim help victim system. This system will serve as a research method to understand the real situations of people facing various hardships and provide better solutions.
Victim-helping-victim is not about finding solace in the thought that "someone else has it worse than me", but rather, the process of problem-solving will completely change our mindset, making us more positive and able to hold a torch in the darkness until we find the way to the light. More importantly, we will form a community with more exceptional individuals during the design process. This interconnected community will be like a massive safety net, accompanying us as we climb to new heights in our lives, rather than being trapped in the identity of a victim forever.
Reflections on Winning
When I received the email, I was sleeping. Waking up to see this message, I thought I was dreaming. I read it several times before confirming that our project had won. All team members were also very happy. Actually, Guo Teng and Li Wenhan are my teachers of architecture filed. In less than two years, they have taught me over 180 professional courses. I believe they are the happiest because with their guidance, I can have chance to achieve my first award in the field of a really short time.
Second Prize Winners
Christeven Cohen & Lawrence Nobel
Indonesia
Lawrence Nobel
In 2023, Lawrence Nobel graduated from an architecture school, and today, he stands as an Architectural Designer with a background in classical violin. Lawrence’s designs are akin to symphonies, delivering captivating experiences. He passionately believes in architecture's power to heal and curates spaces that align with users' needs while staying true to his design philosophy, earning recognition as an emerging talent in the field.
Christeven Cohen
Christeven Cohen, having graduated in architecture in 2023, aspires to be an Architectural Designer.
He's deeply passionate about crafting spaces that foster human connections, believing in the power of architecture to heal. His dedication lies in creating spaces that blend form and function through innovative designs, with the aim of positively influencing society by offering thoughtful, functional, and aesthetically pleasing environments.
Third Prize Winners
Martyna Skóra
Poland
Special mention
José Luis Pérez Hermo
Spain
Honorable mention
Yebin Park
Peikai He, Shang Xinyi, Yangxue Ying
Yihui Chen, Lao Linqi, Zhao Zixuan & Li Xiaoyue
Lauren Konstantinou, Falder Munn
Yebin Park
South Korea
Peikai He, Shang Xinyi, Yangxue Ying
China
Yihui Chen, Lao Linqi, Zhao Zixuan & Li Xiaoyue
China
Lauren Konstantinou, Falder Munn
South Africa